A strange issue I have when sharing music to others

[SuperMarioGamer]

My goal is to compose music that is catchy and conveys profound and powerful emotion.  It would really be no different than how there are, for example, very memorable, catchy songs and tunes in video games and anime.  I plan on composing music like this.  But a strange issue I am having here is that, when I produce a certain tune that, from my perspective, is catchy and conveys profound and powerful emotion, it is nothing of the sort when I go and share it to others.  Other people report that, yes, it is an actual tune since it has a rhythm and whatnot to make it actual music, but that the tune itself is nothing catchy, does not convey any profound and powerful emotion, and that it's a tune that consists of randomly plucked out notes like a cat walking on the keyboard.  From my perspective, I see nothing of the sort at all.  But, from other people's perspective, they see it as being so. 

 

As a matter of fact, the notes of my tunes do have a pattern to them and aren't just randomly placed notes.  I do not understand why others perceive my tunes the way they do and I wish to figure out what is going on here and how to address this issue.  I do not want to produce and share music that I simply perceive as catchy and conveying profound and powerful emotion; I wish to produce music that actually conveys the catchy, profound, and powerful emotion I want.  Take note that I am a complete beginner to composing and, at this point, I am only putting down the exact notes of these tunes I hear in my mind along with a beat and chords.  If you or anyone else would like to listen to one of these tunes I have made, then I would be glad to share one of the soundcloud links to my tunes.  Actually, I will go ahead and share my playlist now for others to listen to and figure out what the problem is:

https://soundcloud.com/user-432115982/sets/my-best-themes

Edited March 1, 2018 by SuperMarioGamer

[Ameni Horus]

Keep doing what you love. Sharing your art with others is always a very personal experience. Think of the joy and perseverance you experienced putting in your time into your craft to bring forth your art.  All that matters is that you did it, you brought that which wasn't to life. Ultimately, I wouldn't worry about what others think too much or how they perceive your art...

Take it for what it is, ask questions regarding but at the end of the day this is your ship captain and unless someone is paying you for your art directly, listen to their feedback, analyze it then keep on doing what you do!

Edited March 7, 2018 by Ameni Horus
Typos

[SuperMarioGamer]

On 3/7/2018 at 11:35 AM, Ameni Horus said:

Keep doing what you love. Sharing your art with others is always a very personal experience. Think of the joy and perseverance you experienced putting in your time into your craft to bring forth your art.  All that matters is that you did it, you brought that which wasn't to life. Ultimately, I wouldn't worry about what others think too much or how they perceive your art...

Take it for what it is, ask questions regarding but at the end of the day this is your ship captain and unless someone is paying you for your art directly, listen to their feedback, analyze it then keep on doing what you do!

 

I am finally back.  I would like to say that the craft itself isn't what matters to me.  It is the emotion that matters to me.  I could make the most artistically and well-crafted song.  But as long as that song does not convey any profound, powerful, and catchy emotion, then that craft was all a waste of time making.