Consider the following scenario. Composer X lived about 150 years ago and composed songs that were sung by anyone who wanted to. No copyright laws even existed. Today, a company releases a CD/DVD with the same song rendered by singer A. Singer B (an amateur) records his rendering of the same song and uploads it to Youtube. The company releasing the CD/DVD claims copyright to that song and asks Youtube to take down the song claiming that they have the Intellectual Property Rights to that song. Youtube checks ( http://www.reelseo.com/youtube-keep-your-account-in-good-standing-really-mean/ ) and asks singer B to comply.
In your own words argue as to whether it is a correct decision. Provide support your view.