John
I have done this a number of times and its produced 1 song and 1 idea that I used in a song; so no, it hasn’t created a lot of diversity. I actually did it looking for inspiration by trying to introduce some random factor into my writing. I used to tune my guitar to some strange tunings and then play around to see if I could find any new riffs. Again this was to introduce some randomness that may not have happened with the standard tuning.
I have only written a handful of songs so I don’t have a lot of material with which I can make comparisons.
Most songs start with verse-chorus (6), verse-bridge-chorus (1) and one song has no chorus at all. At this point I usually think about what the song might need, middle 8, an instrumental, or something different. 3 of my songs have middle 8’s with vocals, 3 songs have instrumentals and 2 have different end parts after the second chorus.
The rhyming schemes I have used are ABAB (2), AABB (3), AABCCB (2), and ABBC ADDC (1). I spent a lot of time trying to find words to fit the last scheme, and I have never been particularly happy with the results.
My songs appear (to me) to have quite a bit of diversity although none of this was intentional. As I am relatively new to this, my priority has been to write the best song I could and I haven’t really focused on being diverse.
Which do you think has more value, being more original or writing better songs?