Hi
Following Olggu's argument, you would buy a car to get from A to B, but if you decided to become a professional rally driver it would ok to steal a top of the range race tuned Subaru.
Think of it from the other side. Consider this:
Part-time Musician: You spend hours, days and years learning skills. You put a lot of yourself in to your work. You write songs. You record songs, burn them on cds, put them on the net, some you sell (if you are lucky) most you give away for free. You don't depend on this income, so that's ok.
Part-time Programmer: You spend hours, days and years learning skills. You put a lot of yourself in to your work. You write software. You make programmes, burn them on cds, put them on the net, some you sell (if you are lucky) most you give away for free. You don't depend on this income, so that's ok.
Full-time Musician: You spend hours, days and years learning skills. You put a lot of yourself in to your work. You write songs. You record songs using expensive gear, you pay to have them put on cds, put them on the net for sale, some you sell (if you are lucky) you can't afford to give many away for free as a promo. You depend on this income. It's your living. It's how you feed your kids. People pirate your tracks, and your sales go through the floor. This is not ok.
Full-time Programmer: You spend hours, days and years learning skills. You put a lot of yourself in to your work. You write software. You make programmes using expensive gear, you pay to have them put on cds, put them on the net for sale, some you sell (if you are lucky) you can't afford to give many away for free as a promo. You depend on this income. It's your living. It's how you feed your kids. People pirate your software and your sales go through the floor. This is not ok.
You might be with a record label or software house. The fact is, if your product doesn't make enough cash, you lose your job. That's the bottom line.
I understand the frustration, because pirate software is easier to get than a race tuned Subaru. But there is no justification.
Piracy is killing the Music industry. You might think it is opening the way for the indie artist, but the fact is less and less people are paying for Music coz it's so easily available. If you decided to go pro, your chances of making a living may be higher because of the internet, but as less people are willing to pay eventual some bastard will pirate your tracks and effectively put you out of business.
All that is then available to the listening public is free tracks, produced by people who rarely can afford good gear coz they can't make any money from their Music, or large label stale commercial tracks that stick to the safe ground and charge large prices in order to stand the best chance of making any money.
Years ago when I started recording, I used a standard tape deck, and occasionally borrowed a 4 track when they came along. I made do with the instruments I could save and buy. I still made Music. I still got my tracks out there. Sure, I even paid to go into recording studios when I started making money from gigging. I saved and bought better gear. I knew that better gear was available (hell I even worked in a studio), but never once did I think it was ok to steal studio gear. I might have been tempted once or twice ...
I had to wait years. In the meantime I made do. I even used pirate software. But i didn't once think I was justified. I did it from more or less a position of blissful ignorance, after all everyone seemed to have pirate software.
For years I saved, I took out loans, I worked overtime, I studied and worked at my Music. Eventually I had enough savings and was able to take on enough debt to invest in some decent gear.
If people keep pirating Music, the industry will more or less disappear as an industry. Apart from of course the most manstream acts on the top labels. Even then they are at risk. The same is true of software.
In the end they will make it so difficult to pirate that you can't, and the penalties so large if you do, that it's not worth the risk. This will happen because they are large industries, and peoples livings depend on them stopping piracy.
In the meantime, piracy will thin out the field and bankrupt all the small and indie operations.
Like it or not, piracy is killing the industries. Each time you download a pirate mp3, you make it less likely that you will make money from Music. It's the same in Software.
What price on giving up dreams? Free apparently... :'(
Cheers
John