Lazz
I agree, but I believe there are some cases where there is a reasonable approach to artists rights.
A good comp shouldn't need entrance fees. Prizes and running costs should be covered by sponsors, and advertising.
On the ownership bit. All a pucker contest should really care about is that they will not be charged for playing entered tracks, including letting the public hear the winning entries, and that they can produce clips of that material as part of promotion. The ability to resell the track is not ok. Most competitions, and others, don't clarify it legally. They simply stipulate that they can do anything they want with the submitted track.
Songstuff is very careful in the contests that it links to, and it doesn't really actively push any of them. I've thought about running contests, but aside from the actual overhead I would need to get a lawyer involved to make sure that I was being fair to artists, without exposing Songstuff to possible legal proceedings.
There is a great deal of benefit to be gained for artists in competitions, but a lot of costs, both direct and hidden., On balance there are a few worthwhile comps, that don't overly exploit the artist, and the benefits for even the starting competitor is tangible. Unfortunately these are few and far between.
On the cost to the artist. Many artists are prepared to cede the profit from a recording to a promotion exercise. i.e. if I give this track away for free, people might just notice me and the rest of the Music. But this tends to be only that recording, not the actual arrangement or song.
As you rightly point out, parting with the rights is a whole other issue. But lets face it, these guys look for those who are gullable or desparate.
If a service is free, doesn't place unreasonable restrictions, and truly does provide a tangible benefit, then for me that's cool (Songstuff more or less runs like that)
If it costs, it still shouldn't place unreasonable resctrictions on artists and their material, it should provide a very tangible benefit, but it definately should be endorsed by respected organisations (preferably by sponsorship), and they should be built on a pedigree of respectable reputations.
That rules out about 99%.
Put it this way. I've never entered a song contest.
Cheers
John