This is why this is a touchy topic! and why I was hesitant to post it to begin with. Even after rereading my post I don't see anything particularly insulting, and I'm very sorry if you took it that way. Most of the musicians I know are improvisers, perhaps this is where our POV's are conflicting. I'm NOT saying theory is the end all be all, but that it has uses going beyond notation and composition. There's so many different ways of thinking about your playing, I'm not even saying that you have to be consciously thinking about how the notes relate to each other from chord to chord. Some of the best players I know are guys who do think about what they're playing all the time. Some of these guys tour nationally and internationally, but this thread isn;t about who we know and what their opinions are, it's about how we all feel individually. I DO respect your right to say theory isn't your thing, I just get a lil miffed when people say it's a hindrance in performance settings. Also, not trying to be a "snob", some of my best friends can't spell out the notes in a C major chord, and they're some of the players I respect the most. Not complaining here, just find this topic highly interesting ad I don't get why so many people are completely against theory.
Again, wasn't trying to be insulting, sorry if you took it that way!